If you have had any of the Amish baked  goods we offer from Annie and Eli's Bakery, then you know they are delicious, full size cookies packed full of old fashioned goodness.

We will be ordering cookies from Annie and making up trays for Christmas.  

CHRISTMAS COOKIE TRAYS
Holly
Holly

SMALL TRAY (4 Dozen)         $24                     LARGE TRAY (8 Dozen)         $44

Choice of cookies as follows:   (please order in 1/2 dozen or 1 dozen quantities)

  • Chocolate Chip

  • Sugar Molasses

  • Oatmeal Raisin

  • Butterscotch Oatmeal with nuts

  • Peanut Butter

  • Peanut Butter Treat with chocolate & peanut butter chips

  • Oatmeal Treat with walnuts, chocolate chips & M&M's

  • Sugar-n-Spice with raisins & nuts 

  • Frosted Sugar Cookies with sprinkles  (best seller!)

  • Fruit Thumbprints-raspberry, pineapple or apricot

  • Pastel Thumbprints- strawberry or mint icing

  • Date Nut Balls

  • Pecan Sandies

  • Peanut Butter Blossoms

  • Peanut Butter Cups

  • Cherry Winks with pecans 

74670545_945020769204281_881560436704351

All orders must be in by December 11th and pickup will be on Saturday, December 19th from 10-3 and Monday, December 21st from 10-6. 

Place Order

Thank you for your order!